Policy Experts, Psychiatrists, Bioethicists Debate Merits of Building or Reopening Mental Institutions

March 6, 2018

On the front of its Science Times section, the New York Times (3/6, D1, Carey, Subscription Publication, 13.35M) reports that in the aftermath of the high school shootings that took place in Parkland, FL, “President Trump has called repeatedly for building or reopening mental institutions.” Some “policy experts, psychiatrists and bioethicists” are also debating the merits of that proposal, particularly in light of the “downstream consequences” of deinstitutionalization following the 1963 Community Mental Health Act, including homelessness and incarceration. Still, “a modern incarnation does not impress advocates for people with mental disabilities, who want the very idea dead and buried, along with transorbital lobotomy, insulin-shock therapy and other cruelties visited on people with mental disorders in times past.”



By clicking “save,” I acknowledge that all fields marked with an asterisk are required. We ask for your email address so we can contact you for additional information if necessary. Your email address will not be published on the public site. Your name and your comment may remain published on this site indefinitely. We will delete any comments that include vulgar language, hate speech or personal attacks, or which do not pertain to the topic at hand. We also may delete comments that include personal information about another person. If a comment is received that contains non-publishable material, we reserve the right to either edit the comment to remove these elements or to delete the comment.

Last modified on 03/08/2018


Back to Top